Hum Tum Shabana Reviews

User Ratings (3 out of 5)

Critics: (2 out of 5)

'Hum Tum Shabana' is a bad attempt by Sagar Ballary

Coming from a comic guru like Sagar Ballary, who has given comedies like "Bheja Fry" and "Bheja Fry 2", "Hum Tum Shabana" is a total let down. Unlike his previous films, this has various scenes from different comedy films strung together to look like a comic masterpiece.

Rishi Malhotra (Tushar Kapoor) and Kartik Iyer (Shreyas Talpade) are executives at loggerheads in an event management company organising a beauty pageant in Goa. They get smitten by Shabana Raza (Minissha Lamba), a contestant. Right from their first meeting, on flight, they vie for her attention.

The film begins with an acknowledgment to Madhur Bhandarkar and seems to be inspired by his film "Fashion". The first half of the film revolves around how the two guys woo Shabana. They give her tips on grooming and the winning formula.

The story proceeds like the old fable of two cats fighting for cheese. Shabana wins a couple of rounds. But for some unexplained reason, she loses the crown. Disheartened, she leaves Goa.

Till the intermission, the plot does not progress.

The second half begins with one feeling as if you are watching a wrong reel. There is a disjoint in the link. You realise that this is a major twist in the story. Shabana lives with her uncle (Satish Kaushik), who is an eccentric underworld don.

Rishi and Kartik are kidnapped by the uncle's henchmen and kept under surveillance. They are also given tasks, on a daily basis. This is to enable the uncle decide who would marry his niece and succeed in becoming the next don. But instead of participating in the tasks, our heroes plan ways to scamper away. The plot treads on a nonsensical path making one feel irritated as the comedy is weird and defies logic.

The absurdness of the script combined with the dialogues being layered with a track of background music camouflaging the effects of the punches makes the film unbearable.

There is less of comedy and more of hamming. No dialogues are worth remembering. They don't leave an impact. Tusshar's performance is an extension of his character in "Golmal". Shreyas just walks thru his bit making no effort to be different.

Satish Kaushik too is so typecast that it makes his characterisation dull. Minissha and Pia are just tolerable.

The screenplay and story offer no originality. Visually the film is colourful, but the editing, oh yes, the editing with the usage of graphics and computerised effects makes the movie look like an amateurish attempt in filmmaking.

The music by Sachin Jigar is a mixed bag. The song "Thank you Mr. DJ" is like a lullaby. And the title song "Hey Na Na Shabana" makes you realise why you make the effort to see this film.

Wonder what prompted Sagar Ballary to attempt "Hum Tum Shabana"?

Review by Troy Ribeiro

External Movie Reviews with Ratings of Hum Tum Shabana (2011) from all the popular movie critics and websites.
Starring: Tusshar Kapoor, Shreyas Talpade, Minissha Lamba, Pia Trivedi, Satish Kaushik
Director: Sagar Ballary

Taran Adarsh, BollywoodHungama.com: 1.5/5
HUM TUM SHABANA is a good idea gone wrong! It has a funny first half, but a disappointing second hour ... Complete review

Komal Nahta, ETC & Koimoi.com: 1/5
Watch it if you want to laugh at any cost! ... Complete review

Usha Lakra, ApunkaChoice.com: 1.5/5
Say Na to ‘Hum Tum Shabana’ ... Complete review

MovieTalkies.com: 2/5
'Hum Tum Shabana', Ballary's Hee-Hee Hits The Bottom ... Complete review

Spicezee Bureau, Zee News: 2/5
Hum Tum Shabana, a bad attempt by Sagar Ballary ... Complete review

Shubhra Gupta, Indian Express: 0.5/5
What do you do with a film which is purportedly a comedy and delivers not one single laugh? ... Complete review

Preeti Arora, Rediff.com: 0.5/5
Hum Tum Shabana carries forward the trend of slapstick films with inane gags passing off as comedy ... Complete review

Martin D'Souza, GlamSham.com: 2/5
It's not a deadly comedy, but at least Bellary focuses on his prime motive - to make you laugh ... Complete review

Mansha Rastogi, NowRunning.com: 1/5
Hum Tum Shabana ke liye kabhi na jaana. A film best avoided ... Complete review